In Hong Kong, the Supply of Services (Implied Terms) Ordinance (Cap. 457) serves as a crucial legislative framework that governs the rights and duties of service suppliers and recipients. Whether you're a startup founder hiring a web developer or an SME engaging a cleaning service, understanding these legal obligations is essential for safeguarding your interests.
This comprehensive guide explores the key legal obligations imposed on suppliers under this ordinance. We’ll delve into the specific implied terms and their practical implications, and how businesses can navigate these requirements effectively.
📜 Overview of the Supply of Services (Implied Terms) Ordinance
The Supply of Services (Implied Terms) Ordinance was enacted to protect consumers and ensure fairness in service contracts. It automatically inserts certain terms into service agreements, even if they are not explicitly stated.
These implied terms apply to contracts where services are supplied in the course of a business. The ordinance does not apply to employment contracts or contracts for the sale of goods, which is governed by separate legislation.
Where a service contract is silent on certain matters, service contract law Hong Kong implies the following terms as against a customer dealing as a consumer:
- Reasonable care and skill
- Timely performance
- Fair pricing
🛠️ 1. Obligation to Exercise Reasonable Care and Skill
What It Means
Under Section 5 of the Ordinance, there is an implied term that the supplier will carry out the service with “reasonable care and skill.”
Practical Implications
- A supplier must meet the standard expected of a competent professional in their field.
- Mistakes due to incompetence or negligence may constitute a breach of contract.
- The standard is objective and considers the nature of the service and industry norms.
Examples
- A plumber who installs a pipe incorrectly, causing water damage, may be liable.
- A software consultant who delivers buggy code that fails basic functionality tests may breach this implied term.
⏱️ 2. Obligation to Perform the Service Within a Reasonable Time
What It Means
If the contract does not specify a timeframe for performance, Section 6 implies that the service must be carried out within a “reasonable time.”
Factors That Determine Reasonableness
- Nature and complexity of the service
- Industry standards
- Communication between the parties
- Any unforeseen circumstances
Examples
- A renovation contractor who takes 6 months to complete a 2-month job without justification may be in breach.
- A courier service that delays delivery due to avoidable internal issues may fail to meet this obligation.
💰 3. Obligation to Charge a Reasonable Price (When Not Pre-Agreed)
What It Means
Section 7 of the Ordinance implies that if the price is not fixed in the contract, the supplier is entitled to a “reasonable charge.”
Determining a Reasonable Price
- Market rates for similar services
- Time and resources expended
- Level of expertise required
- Any prior dealings between the parties
Examples
- A freelance designer who charges triple the market rate without prior agreement may face legal challenges.
- A mechanic who performs a service without quoting a price may need to justify the final bill as reasonable.
⚖️ Exclusion and Limitation of Liability
While the Ordinance allows parties to exclude or limit these implied terms, such exclusions must meet the test of reasonableness under the Control of Exemption Clauses Ordinance (Cap. 71). Further, suppliers cannot exclude or restrict their liability as against a party who deals as consumer.
Key Considerations
- Was the clause brought to the customer’s attention?
- Is the clause fair and reasonable in the circumstances?
- Does it create a significant imbalance in the parties’ rights?
Examples of Unreasonable Exclusions
- A clause stating “we accept no liability for any damage caused” in a service contract may be unenforceable.
- A service provider excluding liability for gross negligence is unlikely to succeed in court.
The Supply of Services (Implied Terms) Ordinance plays a vital role in ensuring fairness and accountability in service contracts in Hong Kong. For SMEs and entrepreneurs, understanding these rights and obligations is not just a legal necessity – it’s a business imperative.
Whether you're entering into a new service agreement, dealing with a dispute, or simply trying to understand your rights and duties, our Ask.Legal is here to help. It's fast, accurate, and tailored to Hong Kong law.
👉 Need help navigating this issue? Check out Ask.Legal — our AI-powered legal assistant is ready to help 24/7.
